> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.communityforwardredlands.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Redlands Unified board to weigh removal of two challenged books
- URL: https://www.communityforwardredlands.com/redlands-unified-board-to-weigh-removal-of-two-challenged-books/
- Published: 2025-12-09T01:12:12.000Z
- Updated: 2025-12-10T06:19:09.000Z
- Description: Redlands Unified will hold public hearings Tuesday to decide whether The Bluest Eye and Push stay in school libraries or are removed.
- Author: Stephanie Hastings Miranda
- Tags: Education, School Board

**VOTE UPDATE — Dec. 9, 2025:**  
The Redlands Unified school board voted 3–2 to remove the book *Push* by Sapphire from high school libraries, overturning the review committee’s recommendation to keep the book with restricted access. Vice President Patty Holohan and clerk Melissa Ayala-Quinerto cast the no votes. 

The board voted 5–0 to restrict access to *The Bluest Eye* by Toni Morrison in high school libraries, limiting the book to students 18 years or older with parental consent.

*Additional meeting coverage to follow.*

---

REDLANDS, Calif. – For the first time since passing its controversial new book review policy, the Redlands Unified School Board of Trustees will hold public hearings this week to consider whether a pair of books should remain in the library.

**Why it matters**: Tuesday will be the first test of the [revised book review policy](https://www.communityforwardredlands.com/redlands-unified-board-passes-controversial-book-removal-policy/) ([AR 1312.2](https://simbli.eboardsolutions.com/Policy/ViewPolicy.aspx?S=36030396&revid=mc6fTPplusb4pR5R5yitOpLwA%3d%3d&ptid=amIgTZiB9plushNjl6WXhfiOQ%3d%3d&secid=zxfvZYmcKkpluslhKHzD4ftFA%3d%3d&PG=6&IRP=0&isPndg=false&ref=communityforwardredlands.com)) that went into effect at the start of the 2025-26 school year. In addition to review committees, the policy implemented a rubric used to score a book’s appropriateness. 

### **Board will hear appeal of book review committee decisions**

Two books, *Push* by Sapphire and *The Bluest Eye* by Toni Morrison, are before the board on Dec. 9\. 

Both books fall under Section II of the policy regarding material alleged to contain “perceived pornography, erotica, graphic descriptions or depictions of sexual acts, and/or sexual violence, or sexually explicit materials.”

Both titles include difficult themes, including trauma and sexual violence.

According to policy, a principal is required to remove these books within three business days of a complaint. A district-level review committee that includes the superintendent, the assistant superintendent of educational services, and the director of elementary or secondary education would then read and review the books in question. 

To judge a book’s appropriateness, the committee uses a newly developed review rubric, scorecard and definitions list. 

The rubric scores books based on five criteria, including: 

- **Presence of explicit sexual content:** *Rate the severity and/or frequency of pornography, erotica, or detailed sexual acts.*
- **Depictions of sexual violence**: *Rate the severity and/or frequency of sexual assault, coercion, or graphic violence tied to sexuality.*
- **Contextual purpose:** *Is the content gratuitous, or is it presented in a literary, historical, scientific, or educational context?*
- **Age and developmental suitability:** *Are the materials appropriate for the current placement?*
- **Potential negative impact on students:** *Does exposure risk psychological harm, trauma, or disruption?*

Committee members assign a score from 0 to 5 for each category. Although the scale labels differ across the rubric, the scoring works the same way: low numbers signal appropriateness; high numbers signal concern. 

The values from each section are then added for a total score. Any score under 10 means no action is taken. Scores from 11 to 19 mean the book would be moved to a higher level or restricted if at the high school level. A score above 20 would result in removal of the book.

### **Here’s how the books in question scored**

Three scorecards were submitted to the board for *The Bluest Eye*. One committee member gave the book a 9, recommending no action be taken and allowing the book to stay in the library. Two committee members scored the book at 14, recommending the book be moved to a higher level or restricted. 

Three scorecards were submitted to the board for *Push* by Sapphire. All three committee members scored the book in the middle range, recommending the book be moved to a higher level or restricted. 

None of the rubric scorecards recommended the removal of the books. 

According to the policy, the superintendent would have provided the committee’s written report of its decision within three business days to the complainant, school site principal, school librarian and Board of Education.

Both decisions have been appealed by the original complainant. 

### **What’s happening Tuesday**

Now the board must decide whether to uphold the committee’s decision to keep the books but limit access, or to side with the complainant and remove the books altogether. Because the item is listed as a public hearing under Public Participation, community members will have an opportunity to speak in person before the board begins its deliberation. 

Following deliberation, the board shall vote to designate the appropriate grade-level access. If the material is deemed unsuitable for any level, it will be permanently removed from the corresponding schools and district facilities within five business days of the board’s decision.

### Community reaction

In a media release, community group Together for Redlands urged the board to stick with the committee’s findings. 

“These committees required both time and district funds to complete their work, and they recommended that these books remain available to students,” said a representative of Together for Redlands. “We urge the board to respect the integrity of that process. Ignoring the committees’ findings would undermine the policy the board adopted and waste valuable district resources.”

The group also points out that both titles, written by Black authors, were selected by credentialed district librarians.

“The district invested resources to assemble these committees, ensuring that the review process was thorough, balanced and aligned with policy,” the statement said.

### **School Board meeting information**

The public agenda item and attached rubric scores can be found under Section 9, Public Participation, of the [school board meeting agenda](https://redlandsusd.community.diligentoneplatform.com/Portal/MeetingInformation.aspx?Org=Cal&Id=53&ref=communityforwardredlands.com). 

The public hearings will take place during the Dec. 9 school board meeting which begins at **6:00 p.m. in the board room at 25 West Lugonia Avenue, Redlands.** 

**A full school board meeting preview is** [**available here**](https://www.communityforwardredlands.com/whats-on-the-redlands-unified-school-board-agenda-for-dec-9/)**.** 

For more on how this policy was adopted and the controversy surrounding it, see:

[Redlands Unified Board passes controversial book removal policyAfter more than a year of heated debate, public protests and calls for resignation, the RUSD board approves stricter rules for reviewing and removing library materials.![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/f5/51/f5517707-3f50-4c01-a20b-337e3a8ce042/content/images/icon/Site-Logo--4--106.png)Community Forward Redlands NewsKathryne Mccann![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/f5/51/f5517707-3f50-4c01-a20b-337e3a8ce042/content/images/thumbnail/Redlands-School-Board-Aug-19-2025-1.png)](https://www.communityforwardredlands.com/redlands-unified-board-passes-controversial-book-removal-policy/)